Resources for Editors
The African Journal of Reproduction and Gynaecological Endoscopy (AJRGE) is committed to upholding the highest standards of editorial excellence, integrity, and efficiency in scholarly publishing.
This section provides editors with curated tools, guidelines, and best practices to support effective manuscript handling, peer review management, ethical compliance, and high-quality publication processes.
Editors play a critical role in ensuring the quality, credibility, and impact of published research. Editors are expected to:
- Maintain objectivity, fairness, and confidentiality throughout the review process
- Ensure timely handling of submissions and communication with authors and reviewers
- Uphold editorial independence and avoid conflicts of interest
- Base decisions solely on scientific merit, originality, and relevance
- Promote transparency and accountability in editorial decisions
At submission, editors should:
- Assess scope alignment with AJRGE’s focus areas
- Check for completeness (abstract, keywords, references, figures)
- Conduct initial quality review (clarity, structure, scientific rigor)
- Perform plagiarism screening before peer review
- Identify any ethical concerns or conflicts of interest
AJRGE operates a double-blind peer review system.
Best Practices:
- Select qualified and independent reviewers with relevant expertise
- Avoid reviewer conflicts of interest
- Provide clear review guidelines and timelines
- Monitor reviewer performance and responsiveness
- Ensure constructive, unbiased, and professional feedback
Editorial Decision Making:
Editors should base decisions on:
- Reviewer recommendations
- Scientific validity and originality
- Relevance to journal scope
- Ethical compliance
AJRGE adheres to internationally recognized standards, including guidelines from the Committee on Publication Ethics and the International Committee of Medical Journal Editors.
Editors must ensure:
- Originality of submissions (no plagiarism or duplicate publication)
- Proper authorship attribution
- Disclosure of conflicts of interest
- Evidence of ethical approval for human/clinical studies
- Appropriate handling of misconduct, corrections, and retractions
Editors are encouraged to use reliable plagiarism detection tools to ensure originality:
- Turnitin – Widely used academic similarity checker
- iThenticate – Industry standard for scholarly publishing
- Grammarly – Includes plagiarism and writing enhancement features
- PlagScan – Alternative similarity checking platform
Editors should review similarity reports carefully and distinguish between:
Potential plagiarism or duplication
Acceptable overlap (e.g., references, methodology)
To improve workflow and consistency, editors may utilize:
- Manuscript tracking systems (AJRGE submission platform)
- Reviewer databases and tracking logs
- Standardized decision templates
- Checklists for manuscript evaluation
Effective communication is essential:
- Provide clear and constructive editorial decisions
- Maintain professional tone and transparency
- Ensure timely updates on manuscript status
- Offer guidance for revisions where necessary
Before final acceptance, editors should confirm:
- All reviewer comments have been addressed
- Manuscript meets formatting and referencing standards
- Ethical requirements are fully satisfied
- Figures, tables, and data are accurate and properly labelled
Editors are encouraged to:
- Stay updated with publishing standards and guidelines
- Participate in editorial training and development
- Contribute to improving AJRGE editorial policies and processes
For editorial support or technical assistance, editors may contact the AJRGE editorial team through the official communication channels provided on the website.
