Resources for Reviewers

Download

The African Journal of Reproduction and Gynaecological Endoscopy (AJRGE) values the critical role reviewers play in maintaining the quality, integrity, and credibility of scholarly publishing.

This section provides guidelines, tools, and ethical standards to support reviewers in delivering high-quality, objective, and timely peer reviews.

Reviewers are expected to:

  • Provide independent, unbiased, and constructive evaluations
  • Assess the scientific validity, originality, and relevance of submissions
  • Offer clear recommendations to support editorial decisions
  • Maintain strict confidentiality of all submitted materials
  • Complete reviews within the stipulated timeframe

AJRGE operates a double-blind peer review system, where:

  • Reviewers do not know the identity of authors
  • Authors do not know the identity of reviewers
Review Workflow:
  • Invitation to review
  • Acceptance/decline based on expertise and availability
  • Manuscript evaluation
  • Submission of review report
  • Possible re-review of revised manuscript

When reviewing a manuscript, consider:

Scientific Quality
  • Sound methodology and study design
  • Valid data analysis and interpretation
  • Clear and logical presentation of results
Originality and Relevance
  • Novel contribution to the field
  • Alignment with AJRGE’s scope
Clarity and Structure
  • Well-organized manuscript
  • Clear language and readability
Ethical Compliance
  • Evidence of ethical approval
  • Proper consent for human studies
  • Absence of plagiarism or misconduct

A strong review should include:

  • Summary of the manuscript (brief and objective)
  • Major comments (methodology, validity, originality)
  • Minor comments (grammar, formatting, clarity)
  • Constructive suggestions for improvement
  • A clear recommendation:
    • Accept
    • Minor revision
    • Major revision
    • Reject

AJRGE adheres to global best practices, including guidelines from the Committee on Publication Ethics and the International Committee of Medical Journal Editors.

Reviewers must:

  • Declare any conflicts of interest before accepting a review
  • Maintain confidentiality of manuscript content
  • Avoid using unpublished data for personal advantage
  • Report any suspected plagiarism, duplication, or misconduct
  • Provide objective, respectful, and professional feedback
Plagiarism & Similarity Checking
  • iThenticate – Industry-standard similarity checker
  • Turnitin – Widely used academic tool
Language & Clarity Improvement
Reference & Citation Checking

Reviewers are expected to:

  • Accept or decline review invitations promptly
  • Submit reviews within the agreed timeframe
  • Communicate proactively if delays arise

Timely reviews are essential to maintaining an efficient publication process.

All manuscripts under review are confidential documents.

Reviewers must:

  • Not share or distribute manuscript content
  • Not discuss the manuscript with unauthorized individuals
  • Not retain copies after completing the review

AJRGE acknowledges the valuable contributions of reviewers through:

  • Editorial recognition
  • Certificates of review (where applicable)
  • Inclusion in reviewer acknowledgements

For assistance or inquiries regarding the review process, reviewers may contact the AJRGE editorial team through the official communication channels provided on the website.